Lending Club Review and Progress

A few months ago I decided to give social lending at Lending Club a try (my Lending Club review). I was intrigued by Lending Club’s business model, and having a little experience on the other side of the loan officer’s table, I thought maybe I could score a decent return.  Here are a few updates from my Lending Club progress report.

For my initial social lending experiment I decided to invest a small amount of money in two loans. Lending Club categorizes borrower profiles based on a variety factors such as credit score, income (which they verify).  I balance this against the borrower’s personal story.  Trying to read credibility in black and white is not always easy, but when you read someone’s story in the context of their other information you can usually get a feel for their authenticity.

To spread my risk out a bit, I balanced investments in Lending Club borrowers between a medium-risk borrower with a low-risk borrower. Both loans are being paid and are in good standing, yielding an approximate net annualized return on investment of roughly 11%.  Not bad for a rookie.

Click for a larger view

Advantages of Investing With Lending Club

  • You have the opportunity to earn better returns than traditional market investing
  • Lending Club is selective about the types of borrowers they allow to join
  • Flexibility to trade notes, or hold them and reinvest (or withdraw) the interest
  • Free to join

If you are interested in investing with Lending Club I suggest starting with a small percentage of your overall portfolio until you get your feet wet.  I think you’ll find their platform very straightforward, whether you decided to invest in individual loans, or a collection of loans.  Of course, I haven’t invested enough to exactly live off passive income at this point, but it’s a start, and the potential is there for investing more down the line.


  1. You seem to be investing $100 only in 2 notes. That does not make sense to me from a diversification point of view. I’ve been lending $500 (20 loans) to try it out for 3 months. So far so good. My return is close to 10%. The reality is that some of those loans will default, but the concept seems to work if you diversify sufficiently. What is sufficient? I’ don’t know, but I’m getting the feeling it only makes sense when you invest in 100 notes (which will be $2,500). i will be increasing my investment in the next few weeks. You can’t beat their returns.

  2. @LorN: You are correct; my diversification is pretty crappy. But, considering I had such a small investment, initially, my risk is pretty low, too. As I add more money over time, I plan to spread the money out across more loans. Glad to hear Lending Club is working out well for you!

  3. I have heard of this. I dropped $75 into it. The actual default rate is under 3% avg. I figure not a bad deal. Great suggestion frugal dad.

  4. I invested in over 50 Prosper loans over the course of 2008. I will admit I got a little greedy and I am now seeing several of them default (9) which has brought my earnings back to break even.

    I have thought about using Lending Club as well but my state does not allow it.

  5. Prosper is like a tired animal that has crawled onto the road but doesn’t have enough energy to make it across and is now just sitting on the middle yellow line waiting to be squashed by a semi-truck;the name of that semi-truck is Lending Club.